I rounded the corner of Fifth Avenue onto 42nd Street fully expecting to find the ‘’Tell Me Off for One Dollar" man waiting for me - in fact waiting just for me. After all, last week, rushing to class, I had had no time to tell him off for even a quarter. But it was not to be. Leaving myself some reasonable time for a good dressing down before my class started, and after a fruitless reconaissance of the vicinity, he was nowhere to be seen. I stumped off, now much too early for class, as the warm sun seemed to retract its rays grudgingly westwards along 42nd Street, its heat adding to my general feeling of dismal aggravation.
I had been very taken by Tell Me Off Man’s concept; also intrigued. He had not had any takers as far as I could see. Unsurprising, since there he sat in his stripey deckchair (of all things), a large black man in a black t-shirt, arms folded stubbornly across his chest. He was a regular Mr. T., inscrutable behind dark, wraparound sunglasses. People swarmed past him, glanced at him furtively if at all, and kept going, perhaps with a little more urgency to their stride than they had before. It was a wonder he had not sought employment abroad with some private security company in, say, Iraq. He’d be so very, very perfect for riding, sheathed in Kevlar, atop the Humvee in a red bandana, all cracked up on power and blithe ignorance of, say, Section 843, article 43 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice. If this felt too chancy, he could surely make a nice living as a bouncer. I couldn’t imagine him not enjoying that mean little club doorman fiction as he stood, looming at the rope, waiting for the poor, unsuspecting post-college cretins in white pleated chinos and blue chambray shirts to approach him, clear in their intentions, only to have him pretend to not understand quite what they wanted; to humiliate them, in front of their jeering mates or tottering girlfriends, by unnecessarily enquiring in an indetectable customs officer type sneer: "Can I help you?"
What was his …deal anyway? Was he really trying to make some money? For sure, he did not appear to be some sort of faux pauvre rich kid performance artist from the School of Performing Arts wedged midway up his own arsehole. Would a telling off provide him some form of challenge or self-punishment? And if so, what ever had he done to deserve it - and were there heads and buckets of blood involved? And if not, if he was some peculiar type of street dwelling masochist, shouldn’t he be paying me for the verbal spanking? I had to know, but more importantly, I simply couldn’t believe he wasn’t there. Wretched man.
Used to be you could rely on such people in New York. Zoning out in class that night, Tell Me Off Man made me think, once again, how much the city is changing. Apparent lunatics are, after all, almost a tradition here, appearing to have a particular penchant for New York itself. They have always appeared on a regular basis and with a frequency unparalelled elsewhere. Ironically so, if you think about it, when their audience, New Yorkers, have perfected the blank middle distance stare that says, "I do not see you. But know also, especially if you’re a bit violent, that it’s not personal, merely I am in a preoccupied state of hurrying or intently checking my text messages here in the subway car, and indeed, may in fact have failed to register the fact you’re blaring at the top of your lungs about Jesus or how you fought in Vietnam before you were born." Then again, and the genuinely desperate and poor aside, maybe it is precisely because of this fact, that some relish the comfort and freedom to just be completely whacked out in public and have no one bat an eyelash. I know I myself have been grateful for this fact on occasion (occasions we will not go into here).
When I first moved to New York, I actually used to work very close to Tell Me Off Man’s corner, on 42nd and Madison. I walked home most nights, and would usually come across the terrifying "Sign the Pe-TI-tion, Ladies!!!!!" woman. Same stomping ground as Tell Me Off man, except she had a much bigger sign, and was surrounded by grim placards, depicting all sorts of alarmingly blown-up grainy photos of various women, always in the same uncomfortable, nipple-ripping, chain-encrusted poses. It was torture porn allright, but worse, it was wantonly uncreative. I say this but then I didn’t have a fair comparison since I never saw the stuff anywhere else; only on her corner. I used to wonder if I should point this damning irony out to her - but I never did, and I never signed the petition either, because, quite honestly, even I am not that stupid.
But not so my boyfriend, S., who, having come to collect me from work one day announced he would actually go "Sign the Pe-TI-tion!!!!!!" himself. Sweet boy. I think he was puzzled that I, a woman, had not already done so, and wanted to set me an example. As it turned out, although he, like me, had witnessed her railing furiously against men in all their forms, he was falling victim to the naïve logic that she might appreciate one of them trying to help. So off he bounced as I lurked at a safe distance wondering what would happen. And what happened was that I will never forget her face as he, a tall, genial looking dirty blond, strolled towards her; and she, a fidgety, red-skinned, equally dirty, dangerously skinny person started to flap her scarecrow’s arms and then… opened her mouth in a howl of such screeching banshee fury that the whole of 42nd Street turned to stare. S. stopped dead in his tracks. He turned his head towards me, looking bemused in the way gormless people in movies look when an obviously menacingly overly-familiar hitchhiker suddenly produces an axe. I looked away, of course. I did not know him. And finally, as realisation dawned - that she was, in fact, as mad as a snake - he fled. And so did I. And after that, we were always on the lookout for her and an opportunity to quickly cross to the other side of the street - much as I do with clowns and people who walk on stilts.
On the other hand, there was the harmless Duck Man, who rode cheerfully around Soho on a rickety old bike to which were attached, in some tricksy way, a LOT of large, yellow, furry ducks such as you might be unfortunate enough to win at a fair. No one seemed to think him particularly unusual or strange. More mysterious still is that I would frequently see otherwise quite sophisticated looking post-diners (usually men) late at night, walking around Soho clearly having just purchased one of the plug ugly things. Since they’d not had to expertly shoot anything off something at the Jersey Shore to actually "win" the duck, their silly grins and the adoring expressions on their girlfriends’ faces always seemed to me rather undeserving.
There are, these days, less of these "characters" (as they would likely be described by some). I suppose less are able to live in the city or cannot afford the commute. The artists, writers, or even just plain old bartenders and restaurant people have all moved further and further out - to Red Hook and beyond, to upstate New York, to Jersey, Pennsylvania and even (shudder) Queens. And I fear the Tell Me Off Man types may be ridiculed, less appreciated or respected for their utter weirdness by the more recent immigrants to Manhattan: the eternally blow dried Heathers and Melissas and the aformentioned doughy post-college fratboys in blue chambray shirts and pleated chinos who are more likely to shriek, respectively, "Omigod, euuwwww!" or "Dude! Check it out! Gross!" rather than respectfully walk on by, stop out of curiosity, or at least enjoy this phenomenon as a uniquely New York entertainment.
Now, unless you’re selling fake Balenciaga bags, or the Euro tourists find you amusing, you are much less likely, as an inventive or slightly deranged yet admirably resourceful person like Tell Me Off Man, to gather an audience on the corner of 42nd and Fifth by offering the unique bargain, in democratic tradition, to anyone at all in possession of a mere dollar to verbally rip you a new arsehole. It seems a shame.
Copyright Britical 2008. All rights reserved.